Mapping the Dimensions of Social Support in Type 2 Diabetes: Cross-Cultural Perspectives to Inform Person-Centred Practice

Madroumi, R orcid iconORCID: 0009-0001-9002-5644 (2026) Mapping the Dimensions of Social Support in Type 2 Diabetes: Cross-Cultural Perspectives to Inform Person-Centred Practice. Doctoral thesis, Liverpool John Moores University.

[thumbnail of 2026MadroumiPhd.pdf]
Preview
Text
2026MadroumiPhd.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial.

Download (5MB) | Preview

Abstract

This PhD examines the conditions and processes through which social support becomes effective in the self-management of type 2 diabetes (T2D). Despite extensive intervention research in diabetes care, the mechanisms through which support becomes acceptable, meaningful, and sustained over time remain poorly specified. The thesis foregrounds effectiveness, defined as sustained engagement with self-management practices rather than as a clinical outcome alone, while integrating acceptability and lived experience as underlying mechanisms through which effectiveness is achieved. A cross-cultural comparison is adopted, drawing on data from the United Kingdom (with participants recruited primarily through Liverpool-based services) and Morocco, to examine how relational, structural, and cultural conditions shape the form and reception of support across two contrasting health systems.

The thesis is organised into three phases. The first phase comprises a systematic review and meta-analysis of 27 intervention studies, which found that social support produced a modest improvement in glycaemic control but revealed no clear advantage of any one support type, informational, emotional, tangible, or appraisal, over another. These findings indicate that social support is not a monolithic construct, and that effectiveness depends less on the type of support provided than on the conditions under which it is combined and sustained, including relational context, implementation processes, and alignment with patients' needs. This pattern motivates the qualitative investigation that follows.

The second phase comprises four qualitative studies conducted with people living with T2D, their family members, and healthcare professionals across both settings, analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Across the studies, identity emerged as a cross-cutting mechanism shaping how support was understood, enacted, and sustained. In Morocco, support was embedded in family and relational routines, with health professionals often extending care through emotional closeness, physical proximity, and informal follow-up shaped by collectivist expectations. However, the data caution against assuming that supportive outcomes flow automatically from collectivist settings; rather, collectivist norms shape the form support takes without guaranteeing it will be experienced as helpful or aligned with the individual's needs. In the United Kingdom, support was more pragmatic and autonomy-focused, delivered through signposting, coaching, and subtle reminders, but constrained by role boundaries and service fragmentation. Across both settings, trust, continuity, respectful communication, and negotiated involvement were identified as key conditions enabling support to be experienced as helpful rather than intrusive.

The third phase integrates findings across the studies through a higher-order synthesis and the application of the COM-B model as a programme-level sense-making framework. COM-B was selected over alternatives including the Theoretical Domains Framework and the Theoretical Framework of Acceptability because its higher level of abstraction accommodates the heterogeneous, relationally embedded nature of social support across multiple participant groups and cultural contexts. The synthesis culminates in the development of the Social Support Consistency Model (SSCM), positioned as a conceptual and interpretative model rather than an intervention. Distinguished from typological approaches such as House's four-component framework, and from stress-buffering and network models of social support, the SSCM offers a theoretically informed account of mechanisms through which alignment of expectations, identities, and relational practices across patients, healthcare professionals, and family members may enable support to remain acceptable and effective.

By integrating cross-cultural qualitative evidence with intervention research, this thesis extends a literature that has predominantly focused on high-income settings and on isolated intervention components. It offers a relational and system-oriented account of how support functions in everyday diabetes care, with implications for policy and practice in both high- and middle-income countries. The SSCM lays the groundwork for future interventions to be co-designed with patients, families, and professionals, and to test the model in practice.

Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Uncontrolled Keywords: Type 2 diabetes; Social support; Self-management; Cross-cultural research; Person-centred care; ocial Support Consistency Model; COM-B; United Kingdom; Morocco
Subjects: B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BF Psychology
R Medicine > RA Public aspects of medicine
Divisions: Psychology (from Sep 2019)
Date of acceptance: 14 May 2026
Date of first compliant Open Access: 18 November 2026
Date Deposited: 18 Nov 2026 16:06
Last Modified: 18 Nov 2026 16:07
DOI or ID number: 10.24377/LJMU.t.00029521
Supervisors: Newson, L, Umeh, K and Poole, H
URI: https://researchonline.ljmu.ac.uk/id/eprint/29521
View Item View Item